I've been kicking this around for a bit now I've shown some versions to a couple of different people. Some liked it and some warned me that I might be cutting off my nose to spite my face. They warned me the festival may black ball me but I can still buy a ticket (then again I think I'm already blackballed but that's another story and has zero to do with this) .
Honestly, until the programmers and the people directing the festival change I am not going to be looking forward to the festival. Sure their might be some amorphous future movie that they might show, in which case I can buy a ticket; or a guest , again I can buy a ticket and go to a Q&A. I am tired of feeling I am wasting my time which is how it's increasingly felt after Subway CInema walked away. With that in mind here is my walking papers from covering th NYAFF.
I think I'm done with the New York Asian Film Festival. I think I'll go to the occasional film here and there but until the programmers change and the selection improves, I think it will no longer be something I wade into with wild abandon and it will just be a film here or there.
Seriously, I am done.
The issue is that since the Subway Cinema crew left it has been an ever increasing descent into "why am I watching this?" The number of films that the festival programs that I have liked, or understood why it was at the festival (beyond "we can get a guest") has diminished to the point where when the festival ends I always wonder why I bothered to go whole hog. To be certain, the films aren't bad, but they don't feel like anything that should be highlighted at a festival that claims it is the premiere look at Asian film outside of Asia. Most years there are occasional moments where the feeling of wasting time passes but this year there was almost no respite from that feeling.
A couple years back I posted a long piece questioning where the festival was going and I think a lot of what I saw then is still true. (That piece can be found here WHERE ARE YOU GOING NYAFF?). Right now I think the festival exists to have a two-week party and have famous people fly in for the festival staff, but not for everyone who walks through the door. In the old days I made friends at the fest because the Subway Cinema crew brought everyone along, and the last few years there seemed to be a distance between organizers (not the volunteers) and the audience. anyone above the ushers never felt approachable.
While I applaud the fact that the festival has gone wider in its inclusion of countries from Asia for their selections, and while I like the pivot away from the largely genre films of the early days, I still don't understand why they are picking the films they schedule. There is a sameness to the dramas. They tend to be very "meaningful" and of a type. The comedies tend to be about young people and feature romance. It's as if one person is making most of the choices year after year.
Most of the films feel like they are being picked via a template or checklist that has to be followed. There should be a sense of the very wide range of variations on each theme, but for years NYAFF has never varied, it's the same number of the same type of films. There doesn't seem to be very many ground shakers outside of the chacklist. The films seem to be chosen via a ticky box method. We need one samurai film, we need a J-Horror film, we need a Thai horror film, we need a Korean thriller. We need queer films for the side bar. And once they have those films they fill in with other films off the shelf that no one other festival picked up, picking as many as possible just so they can say they have the largest selection of films.
And it's not that I am upset that this year there aren't any great films...well only two are- THE OLD WOMAN WITH THE KNIFE, which I saw months before when it played across the country, and EMBERS. (And if you want to make it seem less dire SMASHING FRANK impressed with its technical virtuosity even if the narrative was uneven, and Anthony Wong broke my heart in VALLEY OF THE SHADOW OF DEATH)... any way, I'm not upset about the lack of great films as in years past, it's more that the films around them more and more felt like a waste of my time. And it isn't even that the film year isn't particularly good (everything is great or meh, with meh being the majority of what I'm seeing), it's more that also doing Japan Cuts and Fantasia and Locarno at the same time I am left to wonder why NYAFF didn't get some of those better films. Japan Cuts I understand (they are in a cold war with each other) but why didn't they get the Fantasia titles? Or the Locarno ones?(and there are fantastic best of year level Asian titles at Fantasia)
Seriously, I cover literally dozens of film festivals every year and no other festival, over the last 7 or 8 years, has presented slate after of films that felt dead on arrival. There is no life only pre-programmed blandness which they hide by having guests or a party.
I won't speculate beyond saying the programmers have their own tastes, but the tastes shift toward certain cookie cutter films every year. I know it's difficult to program a festival on any level so I know there are problems just dealing with filmmakers and studios. I know this results in a different crop every year. And I know that more and more many Asian films are getting regular releases in the US through other means, so the selection is limited. But at the same time almost all the NYAFF films feel exactly like the same also rans every year. You can't be programming this amount of blandness every year unless you have a certain taste.
At times it does seem that the festival is making choices purely on who they can get to the festival. It's great that the fest is bringing more and more filmmakers over, but it seems that so many of the film choices are being made not because the film is truly spectacular but because the film will get the festival staff a chance to meet a famous person. The fest feels like the New York Chinese Film Festival from a few years back which I was told was started by a bunch of rich New York Chinese nationals who wanted to meet big stars (Jet Li, Donnie Yen), so they created a festival. It ran until the studios realized it existed just to bring stars over for meet and greets.(I'm not complaining I got do sit with Donnie Yen for half an hour and ask him anything about anything)
I won't get into the scheduling issues such with all films screen on a rigid schedule, everything is good if you live in NYC but not outside (I was told by the head of the fest it is designed for people in NYC), with almost all the thrillers or horror or action films starting at 9 and spread all over the city in such a way that it almost nigh impossible to go between venues to get to films playing after each other if they are at different venues. Nor will I go into how the festival is essentially now a club with membership dues, with things more and more geared to that membership (honestly, I could join if I wanted to - but I don't want to).
But the physical issues with the festival are minor, my real problem is what I said at the top is that the festival, which has been increasing in size year after year, has been diminishing the quality with what they are showing. They are just dumping crap on to screens to keep the party going and to fill the slots around the guests. This despite that during the Subway Cinema run they would shrink the festival because they couldn't get enough films to fill the slots-even with multiple screenings of titles. (Even Tribeca a few years back realized that getting bigger results in lots of dead titles and dilutes the brand.)
And I will not get into their seeming hate on for Japan Cuts which they now has them intentionally counter program out of a long burning dislike and a desire that there can be only one Asian centric festival that matters. There is no need to program at the same time except that you want to see who has the bigger "built in audience". (and it does seem to be intentional on NYAFF's part since dates always seem to appear after Cuts is set)
Somewhere around the 15th meh film in a row this year I realized I no longer want to waste my time sifting through the titles they show. I realized I no longer had any idea why the vast majority of the films from the last half decade were screened. Yes, most aren't bad, but they aren't engaging or memorable. I don't know why year after year I am being asked to watch carbon copies of the films from last year. (And you thought Hollywood was bad) Worse I really don't know why I am being asked to watch the majority of them because they should not be at a festival that was set up to highlight the best of Asian cinema. I say this as a person who has gone every damn year since 2009 and who went back and tracked down almost every film screened at the festival from its inception.
I say this as a person who sees well over 1000 films a year: I would have better luck randomly selecting a better group of fulfilling films on the internet or in a DVD bargain bin at discount store than I would going to NYAFF in any of the last half decade plus.
I used to look at NYAFF and know that I was going to see great wonders, but over the past 7 or 8 years it's become how much time am I going to waste?
Now admittedly I did not see every film. And I apologize if I somehow missed the 80 great films at the festival. There were literally dozens of films I missed, but at the same time I shouldn't have to wade into all 100 plus films to find a bunch that I liked, never mind delight me, especially when I saw over 20 films that were programmed.
Outside of the odd film, I am done. Even though I know this will probably result in my missing something great down the road, but based on the er evdiminishing returns I can't abuse myself hoping to find something good in the endless films. Honestly looking back at the coverage of the last half decade I realize that with very few exceptions the films that were best were the one's I bought tickets for not the titles in the press library. Stepping away as accreditted press just means no interviews, but I will live.
So Thank you NYAFF for the great films you have shown me in the past, but now it's time to move on and make other summer plans.