Suja A. Thomas‘s film is a look at jury trials and how people involved with both criminal and civil proceedings are being steered away from them.
Full disclosure and the reason I'm not going to do a review of this film: My day job is in the field of criminal Justice. I see what is going on on a daily basis, and it is not quite as cut and dried as presented here. There are layers and shadings and its not steering away from tria because its earier, but for other reasons. The reasoning in criminal cases is many cases the evidence is there, why push things forward when there is a good chance that the person will be found guilty. Yes, the push for pleas works against some people, but in my experience it is less frequent than you would think. For me watching the film was a steady talking to the screen because I was arguing with the presentation and the cherry picking.
For me the problem is more on the civil end where things can get murky because in some cases people have signed away their rights to a jury trial via terms of service or service contracts which often move you away from judical ajudication into the realm of mediation with a person of the company's choices.
Ultimately I'm not going to do a review because I don't have the patience to do an extended commentary and discussion on a complex issue that seemed to me to be overly simplified.
My reservations aside THE BEST JUSTICE SYSTEM IN THE WORLD is a solid place to start but it should not be viewed as the whole story, this is a very complex issue and you will need to do more research.

No comments:
Post a Comment