This is a look at Rabbi Shlomo Carlebach, who was a much beloved performer and spiritual leader who was revealed to be molesting young women for decades.
This is an uneasy look at a man who many people considered to be holy and the damage that he did with his desires for young women. I say it's uneasy because on one hand the film is a kind of celebration of the man and his music, however at the same time it wants to take him to task for the terrible things he did. It seems that despite calling for no longer celebrating the man and his music it still holds him in some regard. It's clear that Carlebach cut an imposing figure and like the group of survivors who at one point were going to confront him, kind of backed off.
That should not be read as that the film condones what happened, more to express that, as with many once beloved people who are found to have done evil things, people tend to waffle. That we waffle is human since we are told to try and find the good even in the worst people. That can work with people but not so much with a piece of art. For me the waffling weakened the film even as it is calling for walking away from the man and his music in the final moments.
Worth a look for those curious, especially if they want an intriguing, if not always successful look at how we view great men who fall

No comments:
Post a Comment