Showing posts with label egypt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label egypt. Show all posts

Saturday, March 19, 2022

Feathers (2021) First Look 2022


Bleak black comedy about a woman  dealing with her family and her patriarchal husband who has to contend with a new set of circumstances when the husband is turned into a chicken.

I know I used the term bleak at the top but this film really is. As absurd as it is I never laghed finding the woman's plight crushing beyond words. Set some where beyond Eygpt in a town that is a sytopian as they come our heroine silent puts up with the stupidity of her husband and the uncaring nature of the rest of the world. 

Writer/director Omar El Zohairy has made a film that is  one of the most tactile that I've ever  run cross. It feels like a real place and real family. If you need me to explain consider that there were times when I wasn't sure if this was a documentary or a narrative.

Forgive me for not saying a great deal about the film but I really don't like how this film made me feel.

If you love your comedies and films blacker than a black hole this film is for you

Sunday, June 13, 2021

Souad (2020) Tribeca 2021

 


Souad is 19 year old girl living in a strict religious house.  She makes up an imaginary life for herself which she tells to strangers on the bus. She is another person with her friends, bold and brash. At home she is a good little girl except when she can sneak a smoke on the balcony or interact on social media while in her room. She is idolized by her young sister. When tragedy strikes her sister and Souad’s boyfriend try to sort out what happened.

Slow building and unfolding like an onion, Souad the film requires you to be patient with its story telling.  It is a quiet tale where what isn’t said and what isn’t seen is equally as important as what is. I say that as a warning since I  looked away for a moment and missed the turning point for the film and had to back things up to see what happened off screen.

Souad is a beautifully acted film. It is film with a largely unprofessional cast who make us believe that they really are the characters. I kept wondering how close to a true story is this. More importantly I wanted to sit and talk with them.0

Personally I like the film, but I know if I had not been ready for it’s low key and unspoken nature I would have had a hard time getting through it. I say this because I want the right audience to find this film. I hate the thought that people will go in and dismiss it for the wrong reason. You need to know what you are getting.

Worth a look for a patient audience

Tuesday, November 17, 2020

LIFT LIKE A GIRL (2020) DOC NYC 2020


Zebiba wants to be a champion weightlifter. Working with Captain Ramadan who trained his own daughter to be a champion, Zebiba slowly her works her way toward being the best.

Following Zebiba over 4 years the film gives us a wonderful slice of life for a young athlete. We are charmed by our heroine and the people around her and we watch how even as she chases her dream of glory she never stops being a young woman. I was entranced.

While this is not going to be all and end all documentary of the year or the festival it is still a small gem and a winner that is worth your time.

Tuesday, April 24, 2018

Thoughts on IN THE LAST DAYS OF THE CITY (2016) which opens in theaters this Friday

This is a repost of a piece I did when the film played at New Directors New Films in 2016. Im still not sure about my feeling about the film.

Started in 2007 and shooting was completed in 2010 right before the Arab Spring upended everything. The editing was then put on hold for three years before director Tamer El Said went back to shape the material.

The film concerns a film director struggling to make a film that reveals the life of Cairo, his city, just as it physically and socially is undergoing an upheaval.. As he tries to figure out what to do friends send him material from around the world

Deeply meditative work is going to either thrill you or bore you. Personally I was torn about the film, since I loved a great deal of it, it looks great, it has all sorts of great ideas kicking around, the trouble was that ten minutes in I knew I was in the wrong head space to see this film. Knowing I had one shot at the film I stayed with it despite knowing it was the wrong time to see and truly meet the film head on.

While I can't rightly review the film I can say without fear that this is a film you really must see. There is something about it that haunts you, even if you are like me and not in the right place for it. A heady mix of ideas and gorgeous images this is the perfect film for those who want more than just entertainment, And be prepared to have a conversation after the film.

Thursday, March 9, 2017

The must see TICKLING GIANTS opens Wednesday

TICKLING GIANTS was one of the truly great films to come out of Tribeca last year. It is the story of Bassem Youssef who took his Daily Show like program to the top of the ratings in Egypt only to find himself  getting death threats and in danger of going to jail. The film was so good it made it on to my best of the year list for 2016. It was a film I talked up for the past year and which many people grew tired  of hearing me go on about. I couldn't wait for the film to be released because here was a film about what can happen if we don't fight for our freedom of speech.

And then something really weird happened- Donald Trump actually became President and started to attack the press and anyone who dared challenge his world view. Trump's insanity was right out of a movie or a  dictatorial nation far away from America. Suddenly the story of  Bassem Youssef was in danger of playing out all over again as Trump locked horns with Saturday Night Live. The joke was on us and suddenly it looked like we might not be able to speak freely. Suddenly TICKLING GIANTS wasn't  so out there any more- to the extent that I had several people ask me "what was that film you couldn't shut up about called?"

Now at last the film is coming to theaters. Here at last you can see for yourself a story that isn't so far out any more and really does have a connection to us here in America.

What follows is my review from Tribeca. I could have changed it but this is what I wrote when I saw it  the first time when the passion for the film was flowing. I don't think I could really improve on it - only add to it- which I've done in this intro and a brief coda.

Please do yourself and the world a favor and see this film. Say what you will about the film itself it's message about the importance of speaking up must be heard- now more than ever.

For me the idea of free speech is an important thing. Being able to tell our leaders to eat shit and die is vital to a free society. Its why seeing people such as Donald Trump calling on his followers to silence the opposition is terrifying. The world has become stupidly reflexive to the point that no one can take a joke. Everyone takes offense at everything. People have forgotten that while we have many rights, we do not have a right not to be offended. If we aren't allowed to make fun of things, and of offending those in power then we have lost a basic human right. Being able to do so helps prevent the authoritarian bond because it brings the demagogue and tyrants down to earth.

For the time being, the Unites States is still a free society. We can still speak our minds and make jokes (as long as we are not on a college campus or Trump rally). In theory we can still more or less say what we mean. If we say something, we are not, ipso facto, going to die. However where Bassem Youssef is concern the wrong joke could get him killed.

TICKLING GIANTS is one of the best films at Tribeca. Its at the top of the heap as to the recent run of films about humor and free speech. It gets to the top because where other films deal with the ideas in the abstract this look at Bassem Youssef, the Jon Stewart of Egypt is what happens when you make fun of dictators.

Youssef is not a comedian by trade, he was and is a surgeon. However then the Arab Spring happened he and a friend started doing an internet program in the style of Jon Stewart. As the government changed Youssef was offered a weekly TV series doing what he had been doing on line. His show was so popular that over 30 million people tuned in each night (Stewart's peak nightly viewership was only 2 million). As the political climate changed yet again Youssef found himself in deep trouble as the network dropped him and there were serious calls for his assassination.

Charting the run of Youssef's show from internet hit to TV hit to political target with death threats TICKLING GIANTS shows us very clearly what could happen if we lose the right to speak up. A wonderful brother to CAN WE TAKE A JOKE? which looked at humor and censorship, GIANTS reveals what will happen when censorship comes knocking, fear and death. This is not abstract ideas or people arguing in the streets, this is people with bombs and guns trying to silence the opposition. Its terrifying. It is this real world practicality that lifts the film over some other similar docs.

GIANTS is also very funny thanks to Youssef's refusal to stop making jokes about things. Yes he gets serious but he always seems to find a joke in there somewhere. Life may get dangerous but the jokes just keep on coming.

TICKLING GIANTS moved me. Here is a stunning portrait of a man who refuses to back down and shut up. Youssef's inability to buckle puts him high in the pantheon of those who fought for our human right to speak our minds. While Youssef has avoided the price that Lenny Bruce paid (so far) there is still a heavy price that he is paying.

This is one of the best films of 2016 and and an absolute must see. You must see what a the lessening of free speech will bring.

TICKLING GIANTS starts at NYC's IFC  Center Wednesday.  It will play around the country starting March 21. The film will open in in LA on April 7.

Tuesday March 14th TICKLING GIANTS will screen at the IFC Center in New York as part of the Stranger Than Fiction series. Director Sara Taksler will be in attendance and taking part in a post film Q&A


Bassem Youssef' book  REVOLUTION FOR DUMMIES: LAUGHING THROUGH THE ARAB SPRING is released on March 21.  Mr Youssef will be appearing at NYC's Town Hall on the same night for a speaking engagement and reading. (for more information go here)

Do yourself a favor see the film, read the book, engage and never back down from anything you have to say contrary to what our leaders say.

Friday, April 29, 2016

Tickling Giants (2016) Tribeca 2016

For me the idea of free speech is an important thing. Being able to tell our leaders to eat shit and die is vital to a free society. Its why seeing people such as Donald Trump calling on his followers to silence the opposition is terrifying. The world has become stupidly reflexive  to the point that no one can take a joke. Everyone takes offense at everything. People have forgotten that while we have many rights, we do not have a right not to be offended. If we aren't allowed to make fun of things, and of offending those in power then we have lost a basic human right. Being able to do so helps prevent the authoritarian bond because it brings the demagogue and tyrants down to earth.

For the time being, the Unites States is still a free society. We can still speak our minds and make jokes (as long as we are not on a college campus or Trump rally). In theory we can still more or less say what we mean. If we say something, we are not, ipso facto, going to die. However where Bassem Youssef is concern the wrong joke could get him killed.

TICKLING GIANTS is one of the best films at Tribeca. Its at the top of the heap as to the recent run of films about humor and free speech. It gets to the top because where other films deal with the ideas in the abstract this look at Bassem Youssef, the Jon Stewart of Egypt is what happens when you make fun of dictators.

Youssef is not a comedian by trade, he was and is a surgeon. However then the Arab Spring happened he and a friend started doing an internet program in the style of Jon Stewart. As the government changed Youssef was offered a weekly TV series doing what he had been doing on line. His show was so popular that over 30 million people tuned in each night (Stewart's peak nightly viewership was only 2 million). As the political climate changed yet again Youssef found himself in deep trouble as the network dropped him and there were serious calls for his assassination.

Charting the run of Youssef's show from internet hit to TV hit to political target with death threats TICKLING GIANTS shows us very clearly what could happen if we lose the right to speak up. A wonderful brother to CAN WE TAKE A JOKE? which looked at humor and censorship, GIANTS reveals what will happen when censorship come knocking, fear and death. This is not abstract ideas or people arguing in the streets, this is people with bombs and guns trying to silence the opposition. Its terrifying. It is this real world practicality that lifts the film over some other similar docs.

GIANTS is also very funny thanks to Youssef's refusal to stop making jokes about things. Yes he gets serious but he always seems to find a joke in there somewhere. Life may get dangerous but the jokes just keep on coming.

TICKLING GIANTS moved me. Here is a stunning portrait of a man who refuses to back down and shut up. Youssef's inability to buckle puts him high in the pantheon of those who fought for our human right to speak our minds. While Youssef has avoided the price that Lenny Bruce paid (so far) there is still a heavy price that he is paying.

This is one of the best films of 2016 and and an absolute must see. You must see what a the lessening of free speech will bring.

Wednesday, March 23, 2016

In Brief: A non review of In The Last Days of the City (2016) NDNF 2016 (March 26)

Started in 2007 and shooting was completed in 2010 right before the Arab Spring upended everything.  The editing was then put on hold for three years before director Tamer El Said went back to shape the material.

The film concerns a film director struggling to make a film that reveals the life of Cairo, his city, just as it physically and socially is undergoing an upheaval.. As he tries to figure out what to do friends send him material from around the world

Deeply meditative work is going to either thrill you or bore you. Personally I was torn about the film, since I loved a great deal of it, it looks great, it has all sorts of great ideas kicking around, the trouble was that ten minutes in I knew I was in the wrong head space to see this film. Knowing I had one shot at the film I stayed with it despite knowing it was the wrong time to see and truly meet the film head on.

While I can't rightly review the film I can say without fear that this is a film you really must see. There is something about it that haunts you, even if you are like me and not in the right place for it. A heady mix of ideas and gorgeous images this is the perfect film for those who want more than just entertainment,  And be prepared to have a conversation after the film.

The film plays March 26 and 27. For tickets and more information go here.

Tuesday, November 11, 2014

Cairo Drive (2014) DOC NYC 2014

There are rules we live by and it's very simple if there is space occupy it-that's it- a Cairo driver

CAIRO DRIVE will exhaust you. It will make you glad for the chaos that is New York City driving.

The film is an examination of Cairo and the traffic problem from the ground level. We are in the cars with the drivers and on the streets with the pedestrians. We watch the cars and motorbikes go whizzing around with seeming the greatest of ease. Its like some grand dance.

Watching the chaos of the streets it becomes clear that:

1-There are no rules. Pretty much anything goes
2- Pedestrians have to improvise and hope for the best since there are no crosswalks.

Its a terrifying thing to watch from a theater seat, I can only imagine what it's like from the streets. The whole thing is so ridiculous that director Sherief Elkatsha includes a stand up comic in the proceedings.

Unfortunately it's  not always funny. We see the car crashes and we learn of the dangers to pedestrians via heartbreaking tales. With all of the chaos in the streets its a wonder that more people aren't killed on a regular basis.

I love this film a great deal. its a film that sucks you in and drags you along. It makes you smile and wince. If there is anything wrong with the film is that it kind of loses steam about an hour in as the Arab Spring arrives and things shift slightly. On the other hand it picks up speed again...

One of the must see films at DOCNYC. A must see because you have to see this film big so the traffic images can make you jump and wince and really react.

What a wonderfully cool film.

The film plays Saturday the 15th at 2PM for more details and tickets go here.

Friday, August 8, 2014

The Revolution Has Been Filmed: Talking with Marco Wilms and Ganzeer about the documentary ART WAR

street artist Ganzeer (left) and director Marco Wilms (right) 
The documentary ART WARS made a recent appearance at the KINO Festival of German Films in New York City. Focusing on the explosion of street art that arose in Cairo during the 2011-2012 protests against then president Hosni Mubarak, it’s a film that was resonant and will continue to be so with various audiences for several reasons. Most prominently, it captures a vibrant graffiti scene, a modern form of artistic and social expression that has leveled playing fields and made for captivating exchanges of ideas from Five Points in Queens, New York to the Kaka’ako in Honolulu, Hawaii. Behind the images though is a firsthand account of the use of art, not only visual but across several mediums, to affect genuine change in the middle of a people’s upheaval. Those interested in a first hand account of revolution in action, as opposed to a distanced look back, will be fascinated too. 

In speaking with the film’s Berlin-based filmmaker Marco Wilms and one of its main protagonists, street artist Ganzeer, the world weary pair needed little prompting to get right into the thick of the documentary. Topics included an instance of street art being used to bring a murderer to justice, filming in the midst of turbulent riots, and the use of humor to criticize those in power throughout Egypt’s history.  
---------------------------------------

MondoCurry: How did you initially get into the the graffiti activity in Egypt? 

Marco Wilms: When I saw the pictures on TV in 2011, I was very impressed. I went through my own revolution back in 1989 in East Germany with the fall of the Berlin Wall. I thought it would be great to be part of next big movement in human history. I went to Tahrir Square to work on a script. But I never wrote a script, I just immediately began to shoot. Didn’t know it would take 2 and a half years at that moment. I didn’t have an exact idea, I just followed instinct and  what was exciting for me. I came to a point where I found this explosion of creativity among people. Actually, at the beginning they called the revolution in Egypt the ‘Laughing Revolution.’ Then it became completely the opposite. At that time, there were many people with funny signs and puppets. I followed the creativity. There were huge paintings on the street of pictures of donkeys as police officers and other things that were funny and disrespectful to the regime. Then, I think I saw a lot of graffiti in Tahrir Square. Then I met one graffiti artist after another, by accident actually. I think you knew Anwar before, didn't you?

Ganzeer: When you first started filming him, we did not know each other. I remember walking down the streets and seeing then seeing the graffiti for WANTED, for the search for the police sniper. And I remember thinking this is amazing! The first things to appear in Cairo were WANTED and then the guys with eye bandages. Before these two things, nobody else was doing graffiti. I was the only person doing any street art. So I saw these two things and was like ‘who is doing this?’  And later I came to meet Anwar and understood .

MC: This was a very powerful part of the film...

MW: It was very interesting to see how graffiti artist used graffiti to bring about justice. There was a police sniper who shot the eyes of people. One guy was filming it with a mobile phone. I think he was a hidden friend of the police. He said he was an actor but I’m not sure if it was true.

G: Yes, and the regime pulled some images of him from Facebook where he was wearing a police uniform for acting on a TV show. They said  ‘you’re impersonating a police officer. That’s a crime. And they charged him with ridiculous crimes.

MW: That’s why he called me. My friend called me and said do you want to meet this guy who shot the video and is everywhere on the news? So I said sure. They asked me a few times to meet him outside of Cairo. All my Egyptian friends said ‘don’t go, this is a trap.’ I didn’t go. After 3 days, they said he was downtown and said ‘can you come to this café downtown?’ So I thought okay maybe this is secure. I went and he gave me the video, and everything he said was true. Anwar had a screen shot and from the screen shot he painted the WANTED poster. It was the face of this police officer and people wanted to catch this guy. Actually he surrendered to the cops.

G: But they let him go.

MW: But he spent four months in jail. It was a little success, but really it was the first success where we could see how art can influence this kind of politics. Otherwise they wouldn’t have done anything.

MC: Was there a network of artists aware of each other from the beginning?

G: Not really. A lot of other people started to do street art but we didn’t necessarily know each other. You could say there was a chain reaction. Each week passed by and there was more street art being done by people. By the end of 20011 or mid 2012 there were so many people. But in early 2011 there was really nobody at all making any street art. If you were to visit Cairo toward the end of 2010, you would not find a single piece of street art anywhere. And then if you were to visit by the end of 2011 or mid 2012, it was unavoidable. There was just so much everywhere. But it wasn’t planned. We never sat down and discussed ideas. It was very organic and very disorganized. I guess later is when we began to meet each other and have some kind of consolidated efforts.

MW: 2012 was really like the peak. A lot of young people started making music and graffiti for their causes. There was this group of 15 young guys who were showing each other (Ganzeer's) tank, a very big piece of graffiti under a bridge, one of the most famous pieces of graffiti from the revolution. It’s destroyed now. It was alive for two years in different forms and shapes. So I asked who did this and they said I don’t know. So it was very funny, these guys taught themselves how to make graffiti. It really was a form of a youth movement. 



MC: Can you talk about the risks of filming in the middle of riots?

MW: The first time we went behind the lines, because I needed some shots of the military, we were running with the soldiers and filming them. Then the secret service caught me. They made me erase the material. I was lucky and they let me go. That’s the only thing that happened, just that once near the beginning. Then I became skillful at playing cat and mouse games. They never caught me again. At the end in 2013, maybe I felt too secure and went into the riots too often. Things had changed. (The soldiers) would run to each side of a street and start shooting immediately. It was like a trap. It was very dangerous. I could feel fire, and sometimes something going past my ear. Sometimes I heard ‘boom boom boom’ and you never know. Is it a gun? Is it tear gas? The last time they were shooting in the direction of the taxi we had gotten in. I think they shot three times. In the film, you can see it. These guys are on the corner. I had enough material this time.

G: When did Abdul start shooting? Was it before or after this?

MW: Before. I had some footage from an Egyptian activist, a very young and talented guy. He had a different attitude than me. He was not afraid to die so he ran right up to the front line. He got people yelling into the camera and amazing scenes of the activists.

MC: You focused on some artists whose ideas and means of expression don't fall in line with the majority of the protest graffiti, such as Bosaina. Can you talk about your decision top include her in the film?

MW: It was very hard to find a woman who had the level of creative output as my main protagonist. I was really searching for somebody. Then somebody introduced me to her. For me, it fits perfectly with the rest of the film because she is such an extreme fighter for individual freedom. It’s like she’s living in a bubble. She’s not a propaganda activist like the other artists. She’s a radical propagandist for personal freedom. She would go on stage with a very sexy costume. Even for this kind of nightclub, it was too much for the audience. It was good to have her in the film.

MC: Can you discuss what has influenced you as a visual artist? 

G: I grew up reading American comic books. That was my first and foremost influence. Later, I started to discover design. The broad history of graphic design is also a major influence on my work. In general I’m very much like a sponge. I pick up many things very easily.

MC: A lot of your work seems to encourage active interaction with those who encounter it. Is this something you plan to continue?

G: Yeah, this is something I’ve been discussing with other artists in Egypt. It’s very difficult to do anything now if you’re not pro Sisi, he being the military general now in power. Our strategy is to do really annoyingly supportive posters. They are going to be so over the top and so supportive of him that, even if you are a pro Sisi supporter you’d say, ‘oh come on this is ridiculous.’ That’s the only way you can do it. It’s hard because there are already many ridiculous things and products in the name of supporting him, like chocolate…It’s already too much for us so we have to challenge ourselves and say ‘how ridiculously supportive we can be?’ and see how that works.’

MC: There seems to be a lot of elements of sarcasm in the protest artists' to express their messages. Is this something that has occurs a lot in Egypt?

G: Yeah, for example one of the artists in the film was originally an art teacher at Oxford University. He would go on archaeological expeditions. He once showed me an amazing image of a papyrus that Ancient Egyptians had been distributing. The artist had made it to ridicule the pharaoh. It was so sarcastic and funny where basically they had the image of a mouse sitting on the throne. In front of him are people that are cats worshipping this mouse god. It’s sort of saying this is not who should be ruling; he is weaker than the people. Another thing is an inscription in one of the caves above the Hatshepsut temple. This was not official but like hidden things that workers did. There’s one where one where they have Hatshepsut’s advisor having intercourse with her from behind. The way she is just sitting around and meanwhile she is the queen…This kind of thing appears all throughout history.

MC: In ART WAR you follow diverse forms of artistic expression, but graffiti seemed most important. Was it tough to balance the films' focus?

MW: As a filmmaker I always notice visuals and music. I knew of Rami Essam and the Revoultion Records, a hip hop band. Because of the context of the film, I was obviously looking for political themes, and works that would give the film a poetic frame. I went to some offices and it was difficult to shoot because it was not so exciting. For me, the emotion I found on the street was completely different. In the graffiti and street art there was a lot of messages of idealism and sacrifice and this idea of starting a new society. So I decided to focus on that and let the graffiti artists talk about it. It was exciting to see during a two and a half year period how they developed their tools. Not only the graffiti tells the story, but then the people on the street tell the story. Then the press comes. The newspapers print the pictures of graffiti. Then the books come out and guys like me are making movie about it. All of that, as you can see in the movie, doesn’t exist anymore. It’s completely destroyed. But the film still exists and I think it will exist forever.

MC: Has ART WAR lead you to thinking about another film you'd like to pursue?


MW: Maybe I’ll do a film about Hamed Abdel-Samad, the writer in the film who wrote the book, Islamic Fascism.  He was actually kidnapped last winter. We worried he was going to be killed. Now he is back. I really want to do his biography. His father was an Imam. He read Faust and moved to Germany to study German philosophers and then he started a fatwa against radical Islam. At one point he ended up in a mental hospital. He has a very strong biography that reflects a life of conflict.
---------------

If references above left you with a desire get a fuller sense of the big picture, try to catch up with ART WAR.

Follow director Marco Wilms on twitter and facebook.

In New York City, Ganzeer will engage in a conversation on Egyptian Street Art held at Revolution Books New York August 12 at 7:00 PM.

Me on twitter = @mondocurry


Monday, June 16, 2014

Battle Lines Drawn On The Walls: ART WAR, Kino Festival of German Films 2014


From Marco Wilms, a seasoned documentary filmmaker and true revolutionary in both spirit and action, comes this highly kinetic, explosively colorful account of rebellion in progress. Its entry point is street art, or graffiti, yet its scope is much larger, bringing to light numerous forms of artistic expression as they are employed engagingly to bring about change.  Beginning with a view of Egypt’s struggle-ridden Tahrir Square, a narrator relates the current situation of citizens’ resistance to the Islamic Brotherhood Party to a history thousands of years old filled with cultural battles, some of the earliest of which have been memorialized by visual artists on temple walls. The struggle is shown to go through phases, from upbeat rallies where those hoping too overthrow Morsi’s oppressive regime appear to sing out en masse, to horrifyingly violent skirmishes with both police and party supporters, which Wilms camera in hand, throws himself right into the middle of.  We see Hamed Abdel-Samad, a writer and political theorist, engaged in a sudden conflict with a group of men taking issue with he questioning of religion depicted on his shirt.


The artistic activity is looked at in relation to the struggle and so the view of these many artists comes in rapid fire bursts that one must be on their toes to keep up with. With so many subjects, Wilms has employed clever means of incorporating them into the film. In terms of music, the hip hop anthems of standing against oppression by Revolution Records plays throughout the film, and we see a lively performance of folk artist Ramy Essam in front of an impressive crowd of protestors. Hamed shares insights into revolutions at large, considering them ‘not successes or failures, but history’s engine that brings about change.’ 



It is the street art that stands our front and center, which we see created during risky nighttime gambits. Graphic designer Ganzeer’s clear-cut propaganda style imagery, reminiscent, in part, of Shepard Fairey or Banksy, offers an ‘alternative propaganda to that of the government.’ Then  there are the constantly changing paintings on Mohamed Mamoud street, an area known for being the site of brutal conflicts between protestors and police where many young individuals have met tragic ends. Ammar introduces his work that was made to memorialize these victims. We later see paintings on these walls to express new visions and communicate more urgent messages, in one very striking visual, the public displays depict the graphic disfiguration of some of the unfortunate revolutionaries.


Wilms’ vision does not avoid complications, showing different facets of this period of unrest. A Youtube video is shown of a group taking credit for destroying one of Ganzeer’s murals. There is also anti-protest propaganda made by a supporter of a religious known as the Salafist party. Interesting too is a shift in focus to look at another musician, an electro punk artist known as Bosaina. She is less interested in direct political opposition, taking more personal issues with the censorship of self she has experienced throughout her life, and as a result carrying on a kind of personal artistic protest by challenging a stultifying gender identity she feels saddled with.

Wilms captures the frenetic exchange of these many ideas, conflicts, and modes of expression in exciting fashion, a crash course introduction to a very real revolution. One that will doubtlessly trigger strong urges to learn more about its dynamic subjects.


ART WAR plays as part of the 2014 Kino Festival of German Films in New York on Monday, June 16 at 4 PM at the Quad Cinema. Visit the website for more details or to buy tickets.

Tuesday, September 27, 2011

NYFF 2011: Tahrir (2011)


A documentary on the events in Tahrir Square in Cairo back in January and February when the people seized control of the square in protest and fought to bring down the government.

This is an immediate, you are there document of what happened in the square over the course of the revolution. It's from the ground level, down amongst the people in the square. If you wanted to know what it was like this will give you a good idea...

...and it will probably bore you after a while. I know it bored me to the point that about an hour in I got up and walked out.

Forgive me, but while the film is an important document about what it was like in the square, it's very close to being little more than watching someone's home video of the events. Saying that maybe sacrilege but it's true. We watch lots of people singing and chanting and talking and fighting... But we get no context of what or when anything is happening. Yes we see the days pass, and yes there is the first title about it being 6 days into the revolution, but other than that we get nothing. Its people and events and that's it with no effort to clarify who anyone is.

Worse many of the events we see are only partial recordings of what was happening, as if the filmmakers came upon something already under way and then they stopped filming when they got dangerous.

My constant thought was what am I watching? Who are these people talking? Some of the people we see again and again but who are they? A name? a name would have been nice.

With a documentary such as this, a documentary where events are only a mere matter of months old and were heavily covered on various news outlets, there has to be more than just footage of the sort we might have seen on a CNN report or an Internet viral clip. There has to be a context; and there never is any just, more and more people.

As a record of what it was like this film will have some interest to future historians but I don't think this will stand any test of time.

I gleaned nothing new and for the first time (and hopefully the last time) at this years New York Film Festival I felt as though I wasted my time.

Sunday, May 1, 2011

Tribeca on Line: 11 features in three days

When things settled down and I stopped moving I decided to try out the at home portion of the Tribeca Film Festival. This meant looking at the pay per view choices, which I ignored for now since the two I hadn't seen Last Night and NEDS would be up for several more months (yes months). I then logged into the on line press library and found a whole lot of goodies. Most of the shorts are there as well as about 20 feature films, of which I hadn't seen 11. With nothing to do for three days I decided to dive right in and see what I could before it all went away.

I'm going to begin with a look at the feature films. (A review of the short films will follow shortly.)

She Monkeys

Winner of the Jury Award for Narrative Feature left me scratching my head. There is nothing really wrong with it, rather it's simply not all that remarkable a film. The story concerns a young woman who is training for an acrobatic equestrian team, her relationship with one of the other girls and her sister. Its a nice contemplative film, but there isn't anything all that special about the film. (The sexually charged nature of the film made me wonder why the jury voted for it since that is the only amped up thing in it)

When The Drum is Beating

Audience favorite about the Haitian jazz band Septentrional and the history of Haiti. The band has been around for six decades and has survived and thrived when so much else in the country hasn't. I loved the music which kept me bouncing, but the history seemed academic and the talking heads intrusive. If you're curious give the film a try, though odds are you'll be like me checking out Amazon for some of the groups albums in lieu of ever seeing this film again.

Neon Flesh

I was supposed to see this at a press screening but I over slept. What a loss. This film is a winner. Its the story of a young man who lives on the street and survives by hustling and committing small time crimes. When his mom is due to be released from prison he sets up a brothel so she won't have to work the streets. It gets complicated from there. Think Tarantino melded with Guy Ritchie but with a unique spin on the whole deal. The best praise I can pay it is I can't wait to see it again with my Dad.

Cairo Exit

Earnest film about a young woman looking to get out from her life in Cairo and not repeat past mistakes. Her sister was pregnant and forced to get married. Her husband is gone and now she has a son she ignores. Her best friend needs to get married so she'll have support but needs to have an operation to look like she is a virgin. Her boyfriend wants to get out of his house and go to Europe where he is sure to make a fortune but isn't sure she should go with him. What happens is the film. I liked the film and admire that it even got made (The producer speaking at the talk after Grandma 1000 Times related the struggle to complete it)but at the same time I didn't love it, partly because the script is uneven, mostly because the performances are uneven. There were scenes where everyone seemed to be in a different version of the same film. Worth a look on cable.

Artificial Paradise

A beautiful young woman trying to beat drug addiction spends time at a resort community. Beautiful but a tad slow film won the Jury award for cinematography, which kind of says it all since the look of the film is more interesting than the story which just meanders along. Worth a look if you're in the right mood.

Donor Unknown

This is the other sure fire winner in this group of films. It concerns the search by a young woman to find the man who was the sperm donor for her mom and the related quest to find the brothers and sisters she never knew she had. The film is a masterpiece of construction by eliminating all of the typical suspense (we meet dad early on) the film is free to take us on a ride of it's own choosing. This is good time with good people and we're happy to go where ever they want to take us. This film was just wonderful. I can't wait to see it again.

Flowers of Evil

I started this movie about a French man romancing an Iranian girl two or three times and each time I got to this point just after the opening credits where our hero dances down the road I ended up turning the film off. I turned it off simply because I just couldn't connect to it and had the feeling that I was exactly the wrong audience. I tried. It's not bad, it just wasn't my cup of tea.

Love Always, Carolyn

The life and times of Carolyn Cassady, wife of Neal and lover of Jack Kerouac. She is intent on setting the record straight and crawling out of their shadow. I liked the film but I didn't love it. I think the problem was I really didn't care about the subject. Don't get me wrong I like the Beats, but the relationship between the Cassadys and Kerouac really never interested me, and this film couldn't make me care.

Love During Wartime

The story of the relationship between a Palestinian man and his wife an Israeli. Described in the press material as a Romeo and Juliet, they are really just a nice couple caught up in a political mess that forces them to move to Germany so they can be together. Solid but rather unremarkable. I would have liked this more had I not seen it in a mass of 54 films.

Loving Story

HBO film about an inter-racial couple that spawned the Supreme Court case that struck down the laws against miscegenation. Its a solid little film, as most HBO films are. Worth seeing when it finally runs on HBO.

My Last Round

This is the love story between a young man and a gruff boxer. This is a nice little film that is the sort of film that were it a conventional heterosexual would be enjoyable but completely forgettable. As it is it's still enjoyable, only slightly less forgettable.

And with that the feature portion of the Festival is done...coming soon the short subjects.

Wednesday, July 14, 2010

Haram Alek (aka Ismaeil and Abdel Meet Frankenstein) (1954)

If you want really off the beaten path, this is it. Its an Eygptian remake of a an American comedy classic. Its sporadically funny, but its more an interesting footnote than anything else. Ultimately though its the sort of film this blog was started to highlight.

The title of the print of this film was translated as "Have Mercy" by the subtitles. I think the unofficial title of "Ismaeil and Abdel Meet Frankenstein" is more fitting since this film is pretty much a close retread of Abbot and Costello Meet Frankenstein. The plot is similar with two schmoes who work in an antique shop getting mixed up with a Frankenstein like monster, a vampire and werewolf. The Frankenstein creature is actually a "mummy" that can be brought back to life if someone know the secret (the make up-similar to Jack Pierce's work but made out of cardboard). The vampire is the uncle of a cute girl who is love with a man who has been turned into a werewolf. What I find interesting about the werewolf is that people talk about the condition being a form of epilepsy.

The film is tough going, even for someone with a high tolerance for "off beat" films. The problem is that Ismael, the rubber faced Costello stand in, is too loud and shrill and annoying. Think of him as a mix of Costello, Jerry Lewis and Sammy Petrillo. As one character says to him "I want to stab you with a blunt knife". He drains the life out of the film single handedly. Had he not been in the film this would probably have been an okay cheap remake of a horror/comedy classic much like many Mexican horror films.

Its not all bad, some of it is quite good with some of the sequences taking the Abbott and Costello bits and spinning them out in new directions (a great deal is just copied wholesale). I liked the clothes lines and the werewolf bit for example. Its a small thing that just made me smile. There are several little pieces like that that really made the tough parts easier to stand (and I'm very curious if the translations of a certain four letter word is what was really said). There are also some nice turns of phrase and new bits (combing the statue's hair for example) that are just nice.

Adventurous film goers or those with a real curiosity may want to look for this however I'm not sure that this is something that you'll really want or need to own. Its a rental or something to borrow, I know I'll be loaning this out so I don't feel too bad picking it up.

Out on DVD from Sinister Cinema